Rate A Journal
Rate A Journal is a social platform for rating academic journals.
- Rate journals that you've loved or hated working with.
- Share and compare your experiences with other authors.
- Make educated choices about where to submit your work.
- Pressure journals to improve their submissions process.
Browse reviews by journal
Latest reviews
Canadian Medical Association Journal
3 months ago
Reasonable submission requirements and response time. Only major drawback is publishing fee.
Journal of Clinical Epidemiology
3 months ago
Great journal to submit to. Almost no pre-submission requirements (can submit as one PDF file), and quick turnaround.
Canadian Journal of Diabetes
3 months ago
Straightforward submission and minimal reviewer comments, though approval/rejection response time can be quite delayed
Annals of Internal Medicine
3 months ago
Terrific journal. Reasonably straightforward submission process. Timely review. Often quite intricate statistical review with request for additional analysis.
Journal of General Internal Medicine
3 months ago
Minimal pre-submission formatting requirements. Straightforward submission process. Relatively timely response.
Internal and Emergency Medicine
3 months ago
Relatively straightforward submission process. Overall good experience.
Journal of Clinical Epidemiology
6 months ago
Great journal to submit to. minimal pre-submission requirements. fast turn around time from submission to decision
Internal and Emergency Medicine
6 months ago
Very fast peer review. And also quite reasonable. I want to give them 5 stars, but there was so many annoying pre-submission requirements and edits I’m giving it 4 stars
Diabetes Obesity & Metabolism
6 months ago
Great journal to submit to. Minimal formatting required prior to submission. Quick turn around time for initial decision.
Journal of Hospital Medicine
6 months ago
One of the best journals to submit to. They don’t waste your time with pre submission non-sense. Very fast to reject. And relatively fast to get peer-reviews